NewGarmin MARQ Adventurer (Gen 3) added to the catalogSee specs →Advertise
idk.devsmartwatches & bands, compared
  1. idk.dev
  2. Compare
  3. Approach S50 vs Forerunner 170 Music

Garmin Approach S50 vs Garmin Forerunner 170 Music

What Approach S50 does better (2) and where Forerunner 170 Music wins (2) — every spec side by side.

Garmin Approach S50
Garmin · 2025Approach S50
4.5Score
2 advantages≈ $400
vs
Garmin Forerunner 170 Music
Garmin · 2026Forerunner 170 Music
4.6Score
2 advantages≈ $350
Higher score
5.3Display5.3
2.7Battery life2.9
4.9Health tracking4.9
3.2Sports & outdoor4.8
6.5Smart features6.5
3.9Build & durability3.1
Dimensions

Size comparison

Approach S50Forerunner 170 Music
43 × 4311.442.6 × 42.611.9
Approach S50Forerunner 170 MusicDifference
Height43 mm42.6 mm+0.4 mm
Width43 mm42.6 mm+0.4 mm
Thickness11.4 mm11.9 mm−0.5 mm
Weight29 g41 g−12 g

Drawn to the same scale from the official dimensions (front and side).

Why is Approach S50 better than Forerunner 170 Music?

  1. Weight29 g vs 41 g+41%
  2. Thickness11.4 mm vs 11.9 mm+4%

Why is Forerunner 170 Music better than Approach S50?

  1. GPS battery life15 h vs 20 h+33%
  2. Sport profiles46 vs 79+72%
Specifications

Side by side

To compare: 0up to 4 models
Compare