NewGarmin MARQ Adventurer (Gen 3) added to the catalogSee specs →Advertise
idk.devsmartwatches & bands, compared
  1. idk.dev
  2. Compare
  3. Watch P1 vs Watch S5 46mm

HMD Watch P1 vs Xiaomi Watch S5 46mm

What Watch P1 does better (2) and where Watch S5 46mm wins (8) — every spec side by side.

HMD Watch P1
HMD · 2026Watch P1
4.6Score
2 advantages
vs
Xiaomi Watch S5 46mm
Xiaomi · 2026Watch S5 46mm
8.4Score
8 advantages≈ $170
Higher score
2.6Display8.0
5.0Health tracking5.0
3.9Smart features9.0
Dimensions

Size comparison

Watch P1Watch S5 46mm
37.9 × 45.511.246 × 4611
Watch P1Watch S5 46mmDifference
Height45.5 mm46 mm−0.5 mm
Width37.9 mm46 mm−8.1 mm
Thickness11.2 mm11 mm+0.2 mm
Weight40 g46 g−6 g

Drawn to the same scale from the official dimensions (front and side).

Why is Watch P1 better than Watch S5 46mm?

  1. Screen size1.83″ vs 1.48″+24%
  2. Weight40 g vs 46 g+15%

Why is Watch S5 46mm better than Watch P1?

  1. Built-in GPSNo · Watch P1: Yes
  2. Peak brightness550 nits vs 2,500 nits4.5×
  3. AMOLED / OLED displayNo · Watch P1: Yes
  4. NFC paymentsNo · Watch P1: Yes
  5. LTE (cellular)No · Watch P1: Yes
  6. Resolution (width)240 px vs 480 px2×
  7. eSIMNo · Watch P1: Yes
  8. Pixel density203 ppi vs 323 ppi+59%
Specifications

Side by side

To compare: 0up to 4 models
Compare