NewGarmin MARQ Adventurer (Gen 3) added to the catalogSee specs →Advertise
idk.devsmartwatches & bands, compared
  1. idk.dev
  2. Compare
  3. Approach S12 vs Forerunner 45S

Garmin Approach S12 vs Garmin Forerunner 45S

What Approach S12 does better (3) and where Forerunner 45S wins (4) — every spec side by side.

Garmin Approach S12
Garmin · 2021Approach S12
5.2Score
3 advantages≈ $200
Higher score
vs
Garmin Forerunner 45S
Garmin · 2019Forerunner 45S
3.5Score
4 advantages≈ $200
2.6Display2.4
7.8Battery life2.1
4.5Build & durability3.9
Dimensions

Size comparison

Approach S12Forerunner 45S
43.7 × 43.711.539.5 × 39.511.4
Approach S12Forerunner 45SDifference
Height43.7 mm39.5 mm+4.2 mm
Width43.7 mm39.5 mm+4.2 mm
Thickness11.5 mm11.4 mm+0.1 mm
Weight34 g32 g+2 g

Drawn to the same scale from the official dimensions (front and side).

Why is Approach S12 better than Forerunner 45S?

  1. Battery life (smartwatch mode)70 days vs 7 days10×
  2. GPS battery life30 h vs 13 h2.3×
  3. Screen size1.27″ vs 1.04″+22%

Why is Forerunner 45S better than Approach S12?

  1. Sport profiles1 vs 99×
  2. Weight34.1 g vs 32 g+7%
  3. Pixel density139 ppi vs 200 ppi+44%
  4. Resolution (width)176 px vs 208 px+18%
Specifications

Side by side

To compare: 0up to 4 models
Compare